Inesdar wrote:
So how does the Lith know the future? Does the Lith have vision or is it giving an educated guess because of it's intelligence?
Visions. It's a gift from God.Forlendo Alistar wrote:
I agree that magic should only be bad...unless you have a God character (like Aslan) or someone sent from God...an angel basically (like Gandalf). Anything apparently 'magical' or even 'miraculous' that is portrayed as good, should point to God as the one who does it.
Inesdar wrote:
Hmmm, I would prefer miracles to be said as such. Magic tends to be rather convenient, much like flexing your arm. It comes when you want it to. Miracles don't work in the same way, they work when God finds it best. And when a miracle happens it will overpower any evil present (So no magic battles). Not that miracles shouldn't be present, this is Christian fantasy after all but they shouldn't be used like magic is. 
I find the best way to get good characters do use magic is to make it Alchemy. Which simply means a science that no one understands yet.
I have to agree with Inesdar. Miracles can (and have) been called "magic", but I prefer to have at least one person call them miracles, to avoid confusion. It is so easy, at least for me, to write about "magic" that comes from God, without properly explaining to the reader what I mean. I believe that that was the reason the "wise, old mentor" figure was created, to explain all those details.Griffin wrote:
Unless you would count a special talent that God gave to a race as magic.  That's really what Gandalf had.  The Maiar had special powers, mostly contained in their staves.
That was only called "magic" by those who did not understand it. And, while some characters like that may call it "magic", I like to have someone there to correct them, as with miracles.Neil of Erk wrote:
Inesdar wrote:
Magic tends to be rather convenient, much like flexing your arm. It comes when you want it to. Miracles don't work in the same way, they work when God finds it best. 
Inesdar, a miracle happens every time you flex your arm. (Yes, I know that was cliché.)
Really, what I mean is this: You have a natural ability that is also miraculous. Miraculous because it comes from God, natural because it now belongs to you. So, "Magic" can take three forms.
Demonic power: We generally use this as the powers of evil in our stories.
Alchemy: Simply a science we do (or don't) understand.
A gift: An ability given by God, but operating on a different level than science.