I've seen Avatar and enjoyed it, I wouldn't go to it to learn about morals and spirituality, but you can enjoy it in as it's own, separate, untrue form.
Can I do Harry Potter? I don't care, I'm doing it anyway. I just talked with my mom about Laura Mallory too, so it's fresh on my mind.
The good:
-Love is the most important thing in the HP world, more powerful and more terrible than any sort of magic. There is one part where the Potions master calls the Love Potion the most dangerous potion, even in a room with poisons. Love is everywhere. In the HP world, magic isn't a theme. Magic is there, but will always take a back seat to love.
-Speaking on the love potion, there is actually no way to bottle love in the HP world. Love is a more spiritual thing, a strong bond that magic can't even attempt to touch. Love potions simply create obsessive attraction. Still very dangerous.
-Christian morals of bravery, generosity, family, friendship, kindness, self-sacrifice etc. are everywhere. Jo doesn't push Christianity, but she always pushes the Godly morals; it's a subtle leading, brought on by Jo's Christian roots but also just her own ideas of morality.
-It forces the reader to think about big issues of prejudice, racism, complacency, etc. She doesn't write her books as an escape for readers, but as a place for them to go in, learn, and then come out of with new mindsets, that are, without fail, compatible with Biblical truths.
-Her writing is phenomenal. Her characters are complex, and her world is so real with it's own sports, creatures, races, and schools. She's written a whole book on her magical sport; obviously she did the thing right.
-Her good characters aren't always good. They're real. They make mistakes, sometimes even do really awful things. It's like the real world, like real war. This is a matter of opinion, but I think it's good. Many people have problems with HP because they think Jo is saying people on the good side are simply good through completely their own merit, but showing good characters still doing awful things shows that no, Jo is saying nothing of the like.
-Personal stuff here: The HP books have brought me together with Muslim-, Buddhist, atheist, and Christian friends to discuss deep things like morality, spirituality, etc. Before I read HP, I could never talk about these things with any friends but Christian ones, because there was nothing that brought us together in that way. I hope I don't even have to say why this is awesome.
-There is such a spiritual side to HP, not in the sense of connecting with the spiritual, but in the sense of souls and the afterlife. I couldn't possibly go into all of it, but it's all very thought provoking and lovely how she writes it.
-When you look into certain parts of the spiritual side of HP, you find that faith is very important.
The bad:
-Magic is portrayed simply as an ability and a weapon, not any sort of demonic thing, as it is Biblicaly.
-God is not present as a real being.
-Wizards and witches, after death, can choose to either come back as a ghost* or go on, presumably to a sort of afterlife. Obviously not Christian in that sense, though see footnotes.
-Some content can be considered "scary" for some people, especially children.
*A very stupid course to take, I believe the quote is something like "Ghosts are souls who, for some reason, chose to remain on this earth." The quest for immortality is always futile, and leads to devastating results.
I hope that wasn't too "debate-y." If anything I said was, I can delete it.
I'd also like to say that HP is not and will never be and shouldn't be taken as an allegory. Don't try and say certain characters are supposed to be certain things; it doesn't work. That is all.
|
I read an article by Dave Hunt on it, that was very interesting 
It was like Pocahontas and Dances with Wolves sci-fi version. XD I'm not saying the movie's bad, I just thought the plot wasn't very original for the amazing graphics it had. 
)
