Oh, all right. *relents*

Bethany: 3
Elanhil: 1-2
Joe Clemons: 3

Elanor... I can't do yours until you guess all of them or it gives away too much. Just randomly match them if you must.

Where are you people's spreadsheets?

*stares at the number three* Yah...I give up. Y'all get to toy with my mind once by making me guess, but there is no way I'm figuring out who I got right and who I got wrong. Nope. Not gonna let this bother me...not...at...all... *head/desk*

If you want to show mercy, move this out of the Announcements room so that I stop thinking there might be something important in there every time I look at the index.

No! Let us guess! I am the master at this...remember the drabble challenge?

Is mine 1 or 2?

I will formulate another guess with my mis-information.

Seer is Elrond
Hannah is Galadriel
Jay is Aragorn
Tim is Gandalf
Vanya is Celebrian
Airianna is Arwen
Inesdar is Glorfindel

I know, very similar to first guesses, but it's what I'm going with.

Love the new ring, folks! It's gorgeous!

Elanhil: you got three right.
Glad someone is finally playing my game!

Moving to General Discussion.
And... time to bug somebody about a certain announcement feature...

Good job, Elanhil! Way to play the game! No answers! Not until you guys guess them all right! Then we will let you know *evil laugh *

Us tortured people should form a pack and try to solve the puzzle together as oppose to figuring it out by ourselves and only getting a sparing few right each time.

Not that I'm letting this bother me...

I have no idea what you meant by the last question...

Anyways, I have a question! When I first posted I put Airi as Arwen and Hannah as the other person who's name I cannot spell, but then I switched the two because I thought I was totally wrong. So did I get three right in the original post or the one that is posted now?

Uh... you edited the list, right? because I only know of one post...

I did this list today, based off of what is currently posted. So the one you posted now. Provided I understand what you're asking.

Okay, thanks!

Is it cheating to get the gender wrong on purpose to narrow the guesses down?

Seer is Elrond
Hannah is Galadriel
Jay is Aragorn
Vanya is Gandalf
Tim is Celebrian
Inesdar is Arwen
Airianna is Glorfindel

Methinks it would be more efficient to use the correct genders ...

*grumbles* Fine, I'll make a better guess... after a short nap...

You do realize their are 144 different combinations of names if you keep the genders correct? That'll take more than a spreadsheet to figure out, but I will go do some mind-game math on the answers so far...

So far I have only 2 sets of guesses to work with, and when you are dealing with seven things the math gets hard fast. You guys keep farming out guesses and I will do my mind games on them.

However, those two have done some awesome revealing. They both have three right, but unfortunately for us stat workers they agree on two points. Thus, we are fairly sure now that Arwen is Airi, and that Gandalf is Tim, because that is where they agree. Assuming that, which is the least helpful situation for figuring out the whole, it means they both got one other one right that the other did not get. Once I see a couple more guess sheets I can probably figure it all out by good math work. *Cannot believe that HW is now making him do math*

Elanhil, you only got one right.

Some of these are so totally obvious, you don't need math. Shall I give you a hint for the easiest one?

Elrond is Inesdar.
Galadriel is Vanya Katerina Jaynin.
Aragorn is Sir Emeth Mimetes.
Arwen is Airianna Valenshia.
Gandalf is Timotheus.
Celebrien is Hannah Marie.
Glorfindel is Seer.

You got 4 right, Bethy.

Elrond is Sir Emeth Mimetes.
Galadriel is Airianna.
Aragorn is Seer.
Arwen is Vanya.
Gandalf is Shar-err....Inesdar.
Celebrien is Hannah Marie.
Glorfindel is Timotheus.

Better?.... I hope we don't have a limited amount of guesses...

only 1 right, now.

And no, you can guess as much as you like.

Elrond is Inesdar.
Galadriel is Vanya Katerina Jaynin.
Aragorn is Sir Emeth Mimetes.
Arwen is Airianna Valenshia.
Gandalf is Timotheus.
Celebrien is Hannah Marie.
Glorfindel is Seer.

Maybe that is right....not sure anymore. I'm just flipping the names of the boys...since I think I have the girls right. *head/desk*

You have 4 right, Bethy.

You can't give me any hints?....just because you loooove me? (You know, we need to get Sir Emeth to make a smiley with really big puppy eyes. Like the "shock" smiley...but begging)


Elrond is Inesdar.
Galadriel is Vanya Katerina Jaynin.
Aragorn is Sir Emeth Mimetes.
Arwen is Hannah Marie.
Gandalf is Timotheus.
Celebrien is Airianna Valenshia.
Glorfindel is Seer.

2 right.

Come on, some one help her out!

*sigh* Okay....going to start over....

Upon finishing up keeping my sister from opening my locked bedroom door...this is what I came up with:

I think these three are right:
Elrond is Seer
Aragorn is Sir Emeth
Galadriel is Vanya

These four are guesses:

Arwen is Airianna
Celebrian is Hannah Marie
Gandalf is Inesdar
Glorfindel is Timotheus

And....that's the best I can do...

Working off of Bethy's info and some other info scattered about. Here is my guess (with, of course, Bethy's involvement):

--Aragorn is Sir Emeth Mimetes.
--Arwen is Airianna Valenshia.
--Celebrien is Hannah Marie.
--Elrond is Timotheus.
--Galadriel is Vanya Katerina Jaynin.
--Gandalf is Seer.
--Glorfindel is Inesdar.

Beth, you had 4.
Vili... you have 7.

Vilisse got it.
Now you all know our secret.

I can give you all the various reasons and complications, hints and stories surrounding said characters now too.

Yay!!! *claps and throws tacos in the air* I'm done then. *walks out of thread*

*Closes spreadsheet*

I just figured it out, too...

Oh well, maybe next time, eh?

Well done guys!

No Fair! Bethany and Vili ganged the thing before I could do it my mathematical way... not fair... They STOLE It From Us!