Griffin wrote:
What would happen if you smashed an ice M'istarel, but didn't take the jewel? What do they do when they have no one controlling them? What if you succeeded in taking the gem, but gave it back? Would the (M)Istarel become friend with you, or try and kill you?
Ooh, great questions! Let me see... if you didn't take the jewel, they would not be destroyed, so they'd re-form, same as if you'd only "cut off" a certain portion. However, they can also be "shattered" by clashing them with their opposite element - fire v. water, earth v. air, smoke v. ice, dust v. mist. In the latter case, if their jewel survives, they will re-form around the jewel after exactly one year.
If no one is controlling them, they tend to attach themselves to one object in nature, usually something with a connection to their element, and guard it from harm.
If you succeed in taking their gem, but gave it back, they would be bound by their code to spare your life for as long as they endure.
Griffin wrote:
I would first try and talk with them, if that is possible, and if not, I would drop my dagger to show I didn't want to harm them and hope they didn't obliterate me.
Suiauthon wrote:
I'd do what Griffin said with the addition of some serious praying.


Good ideas there, guys... Speech could be useful, since the M'Istarel understand the common tongue. For the Istarel, though, you'd still be in trouble. In the event that they were actually out to kill you... I think prayer might be a mighty fine idea

.